Pros and Cons of a South Sumatra surf trip
Surfers are an extremely diverse bunch all with contrary views of the perfect surf destination. Big wave chargers, long board enthusiasts, pros and wanna be pros, kooks, Social Media heros, loners, Glamazons, Amazons, hanger-ons and everything in-between. One surfer's paradise can certainly be another surfer's nightmare, and we've witnessed many surfers in Krui facing both. The pros and cons of a surf destination only make sense by first establishing a context.
If you're considering a surf trip to Pesisir Barat (South West Sumatra) we'll assume you're not looking for another Bali or Lombok style adventure. Nor in need of a Jalan Kayu Aya ("Eat Street"), party scene or fake tourist cultural experience. Surfing is what you're after.
Pros of surfing South Sumatra
- All the waves are easily accessible and a paddle out.
- There's a variety of reef breaks, beach breaks, lefts and rights.
- Plently of bigger days over 2.4 mtrs and small days under 2 mtrs.
- Smaller shoulder season crowds than other destinations.
- Very small and not hardcore local surf community.
- No pro surfers based in the area and few visit the area.
- Tourism accounts for less than 2.5% of Pesisir Barat's GDP. Foreign tourists don't dominate here but are a tolerated commodity.
- No night life or party hangouts. That's right zero. A big night out equals Karaoke at your resort / surf camp.
- Conservative Muslim population that doesn't want foreigners influencing their communities.
Cons of surfing South Sumatra
- Extremely inconsistent with narrow swell windows at most breaks.
- Choice of surf breaks is limited to one or two breaks working on that day or tide.
- No consistent World Class Waves, only waves that sometimes produce World Class days.
- No Java style Indo wave machines that pump out waves day after day.
- Poor or flat conditions can last over a week even during peak season.
- One month or more is recommended to ensure you score decent waves.
- Crowded lineups during peak season when the surfable wave face is below 3mtrs.
- Absolutely nothing to do other than surf.
- Collapsing infrastructure with slow patchy Wifi and power supply. A Digital Nomad's nightmare.
What's our take on the area?
After visiting the area for 15 years during every season, and speaking to hundreds of surfers of all abilities from every corner of the world, it's become obvious South West Sumatra is one of those places that gets under your skin. Love it or hate it you'll likely never forget your time here.
Below are things we've picked up over the years.
- If you're an intermediate+ level surfer with stoke and ability to surf mellow 1.4 or heavy 3+ mtr wave faces you'll get the most out of the area.
- If you're usual destination is Bali you'll be itching to leave after a few days.
- If you're from the Sunshine Coast or Central Coast of New South Wales Australia you'll be stoked.
- If you're from Chile you might wish you stayed at home.
- If you're expecting an uncrowded surf destination you're 10 years too late.
- If you're relying on fast reliable wifi access for work you'll be freaking out.
- If you're a non-surfing companion you might be bored out of your mind.